Skip to main content

KIRO Coach

Independence: How Truly Are We Helping Our Kids Become Independent?

raising independent teenagers

We say we want independent children.

We want them to be able to make good decisions.
Speak up for themselves.
Solve problems.
Manage their money.
Look after themselves.
Navigate life without needing us for every little thing.

We want them to grow into adults who can stand on their own two feet.

But recently, I’ve been asking myself a rather uncomfortable question:

How much opportunity do we actually give our children to practise being independent?

Because wanting an independent child and raising an independent child are two very different things.

And sometimes, without even realising it, we can make independence rather difficult.

“Let me just do it.”

I think most parents have said this.

“Give it to me.”

“I’ll do it.”

“Let me sort it.”

“There’s no time; I’ll just do it myself.”

And honestly, I get it.

Sometimes we’re rushing. Sometimes they’re taking FOREVER to do something that would take us 30 seconds. Sometimes we’re tired and simply don’t have the patience to watch them figure something out.

So we step in.

And there’s nothing wrong with helping our children.

But if we’re constantly doing things for them because it’s quicker, easier or less stressful, they don’t get the opportunity to develop the skills we’re eventually going to expect them to have.

Then one day they’re 17 and we’re wondering:

“Why can’t you do anything for yourself?”

Well… perhaps we’ve been doing quite a lot for them.

We say we want them to make good decisions, but how much do we let them make?

This is a tricky one, particularly for those of us who grew up in cultures where parents are expected to know best.

We often have very clear ideas about what our children should do.

What subjects they should choose.

What activities they should participate in.

What they should wear.

Who they should spend time with.

How they should spend their money.

What they should say.

Sometimes, of course, that’s our job.

Children and teenagers still need boundaries, guidance and parental oversight.

But there is a difference between guiding a decision and making every decision for them.

If we make every decision, how do they learn to make good ones?

Independence requires practice.

They need opportunities to think:

“What are my options?”

“What could happen if I choose this?”

“What do I actually think?”

“What would be the sensible thing to do?”

And yes, sometimes they will get it wrong.

That’s part of the process.

And then there’s the rescuing.

They forgot something at home.

We rush it to school.

They left their homework until the last minute.

We get involved.

They’ve fallen out with a friend.

We’re immediately on the phone trying to sort it out.

They’ve made a mistake.

We’re desperate to protect them from the consequences.

Again, there are times when we absolutely need to step in.

But if we constantly remove every difficult experience, what exactly are they learning?

Sometimes the lesson isn’t in us fixing the problem.

Sometimes the lesson is in experiencing the problem and figuring out what to do next.

Our children need to know that mistakes aren’t the end of the world.

They need to experience the discomfort of getting something wrong and discovering that they can recover.

Because that’s life.

We also need to stop confusing obedience with independence.

This one is particularly important.

A child who does exactly what they’re told isn’t necessarily an independent child.

They may simply be a very obedient child.

Independence requires something different.

It requires a young person to eventually be able to think:

“What do I think?”

“What should I do?”

“What are the consequences?”

“What choice makes sense here?”

That’s very different from:

“What did Mum say I should do?”

Our job isn’t simply to raise children who follow instructions.

Ultimately, we want to raise young people who can think, reason, make decisions and take responsibility for themselves.

And that means we have to give them room to practise those skills while we’re still around to guide them.

Independence doesn’t suddenly begin at 18.

This is where I think we sometimes get it wrong.

We can spend years managing practically everything for our children and then suddenly expect them to become independent because they’re approaching adulthood.

But independence isn’t a switch we flick.

It’s built gradually.

A five-year-old putting their shoes on.

An eight-year-old packing their own school bag.

A ten-year-old making themselves a simple breakfast.

A twelve-year-old managing their homework with less supervision.

A fourteen-year-old learning to manage some of their own money.

A sixteen-year-old navigating public transport.

A seventeen-year-old making an appointment, communicating with an adult or solving a problem without immediately handing it back to Mum or Dad.

These may seem like tiny things.

They’re not.

They’re repetitions.

Little opportunities to develop competence, confidence and responsibility.

The small things are the training ground for the big things.

But here’s the bit I think we don’t talk about enough.

Sometimes we’re the ones who struggle with our children’s independence.

Because when they’ve always needed us, being needed can feel good.

It can make us feel useful.

It can make us feel like we’re doing our job.

And when they start doing things for themselves, there can be a strange feeling of…

“Wait. You don’t need me to do that anymore?”

But our children’s growing independence isn’t a rejection of us.

It’s actually evidence that we’ve given them the skills to move forward.

And I don’t want my children to reach adulthood and think:

“I don’t need my parents anymore.”

I want them to think:

“I know I can handle this, but I also know I can call my parents when I need them.”

That’s a very different kind of independence.

Independence doesn’t mean never needing help.

This is an important distinction.

An independent person isn’t someone who does everything alone.

It’s someone who knows what they can handle, knows when they need help and has the confidence to ask for it.

That’s what I want for my children.

Not:

“I don’t need anyone.”

But:

“I’ll have a go myself first. And if I can’t figure it out, I’ll ask for help.”

That’s maturity.

So perhaps we need to ask ourselves a different question.

Instead of:

“How can I make sure my child is okay?”

Maybe sometimes we need to ask:

“What can my child learn from this?”

Instead of:

“How can I fix this?”

Try:

“How can I help them figure this out?”

Instead of:

“I’ll do it because it’s quicker.”

Perhaps:

“I’ll give you the time to learn.”

And instead of stepping in at the first sign of struggle:

“Let me see what you can do before I jump in.”

Because sometimes the most loving thing we can do isn’t to make life easier for our children.

It’s to prepare them for the parts of life we won’t be able to make easier.

And that means allowing them to try.

Allowing them to struggle a little.

Allowing them to make mistakes.

Allowing them to experience consequences.

And, perhaps most importantly, allowing ourselves to resist the urge to swoop in and save the day.

Because our ultimate goal isn’t to raise children who don’t need us.

It’s to raise children who know how to function when we’re not there.

And that’s a very different kind of parenting.

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Share the Post:

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *