Skip to main content

KIRO Coach

Resilience Is Built in the Place of Discomfort

“These children are too soft.”

I’ve heard it at parties, at the school gate, in the church car park and, let’s be honest, in my own kitchen.

“This generation isn’t resilient. One small thing, and they fold.”

And every time, I want to raise my hand and ask one awkward question: who made life so soft for them?

Because our children didn’t design the world they’re growing up in. We did. We drive them everywhere. We email the teacher about the unfair mark. We cut the meat, tidy the room, and chase the forgotten PE kit to school at 9am. We do it out of love. But here’s the thing I keep coming back to as a mum and as a coach: resilience is built in the place of discomfort. If we remove every uncomfortable moment, we also remove every chance to grow the very muscle we complain is missing.

 

My confession: we ran a tight ship

When my two were little, I was strict. Proper Naija-mum strict. Discipline, values and boundaries were not up for negotiation in our house. Bedtimes were bedtimes. Chores were chores. “I don’t feel like it” was not a reason; it was a feeling, and feelings were welcome to come along for the ride; they just weren’t driving.

Fast forward to now. One is a table tennis player training on the GB pathway. The other, in his final year in high school, scored a hat trick to win his team a historic Scottish U18 rugby final. He is still big on rugby but chose to study mechanical engineering at university. Both are self-disciplined in a way that still surprises me. Did the tight ship do that? Honestly? Who knows? They have their own wiring, their own grace and their own grit.

But I’m a former analyst, so “who knows” was never going to be good enough for me. I went looking at what the research actually says. Some of it confirmed what I believed. Some of it gently corrected me. Both are worth sharing.

 

What the research actually says

This blog is research-heavy, but please hang with me; we have to go there. 

  1. Self-control in childhood follows children into adulthood. The Dunedin Study in New Zealand tracked about 1,000 children from birth to 32. Children as young as three who scored lower on self-control were more likely to struggle with health, money and the law as adults, even after accounting for IQ and family background. And here’s the hopeful bit: children whose self-control improved as they grew did better than predicted. Self-discipline isn’t fixed. It can be built.
  2. Not all stress is the enemy. Harvard’s Center on the Developing Child separates stress into three kinds. Positive stress is the short, manageable kind: a first day somewhere new, a jab at the GP. Tolerable stress is more serious but cushioned by a supportive adult. Toxic stress is strong, frequent, prolonged adversity with no one buffering it. The first two help children grow. The third harms them. So “discomfort is good” needs one important footnote: the right dose, with the right adult nearby.
  3. A little adversity beats none at all. A 2010 study by psychologist Mark Seery followed nearly 2,400 adults and found a U-shaped pattern. People with some lifetime adversity reported better wellbeing and coped better with new setbacks than those who had faced either a lot of adversity or none at all. Seery suggested every day, ordinary challenges likely build resilience too. It’s correlational, so it doesn’t prove cause and effect, but it fits what many of us have seen with our own eyes.
  4. Resilience is “ordinary magic”. Ann Masten, one of the leading researchers in this field, describes resilience not as a rare superpower but as something that grows from everyday things: relationships, routines, skills, and purpose. Which means it’s within reach of every family, not just the “tough” ones.

 

The twist: being strict on its own isn’t the secret sauce.

This is where the research corrected me, and where I think a lot of us strict parents need to sit down and listen.

Decades of work, going back to psychologist Diana Baumrind, draws a line between two kinds of firm parenting. Authoritarian parenting is high control, low warmth: “because I said so”. Authoritative parenting is high expectations with high warmth: clear rules, explained, inside a relationship where the child feels known. Study after study, across many cultures, links authoritative parenting with better self-regulation and authoritarian parenting with worse.

That includes research with African American families, where firm limits set within warmth and responsiveness went hand in hand with better self-regulation in children. Firmness wasn’t the problem. Firmness without warmth was.

And here’s the plot twist I didn’t expect. A University of Minnesota study followed 422 children from age 2 to 10. “Overcontrolling” parents (telling a toddler exactly what to play with, how to play with it, how to tidy up, and being too strict or demanding) had children with poorer emotional and behavioural regulation at 5, and more emotional and school problems at 10.

Read that again. The strict parent and the helicopter parent can be the same parent. Both can rob a child of the chance to manage things for themselves. One does it by rescuing. The other does it by controlling. Neither lets the child practise.

So when I say we ran a tight ship, I now say it with a qualifier. A tight ship with a warm captain. Rules without relationship breed rebellion. Relationship without rules breeds entitlement. The magic is in the combination.

 

The comfort trap

Many of us grew up in environments where running errands down the street at seven, sorting out our own playground wahala, and walking home with no phone and no tracker. Our parents weren’t reading parenting books. They were busy. And somehow that “benign neglect” gave us something.

Psychologist Peter Gray and colleagues made a similar case in a 2023 review in The Journal of Paediatrics. They argue that a big driver of rising anxiety and depression in young people is the steady decline, since the 1960s, in children’s chances to play, roam and do things without adults directing them. Independent activity, they say, builds an internal sense of control: I can handle things. What I do makes a difference. Take it away, and you get children who feel life just happens to them.

To be fair, this is still debated. Some researchers put more weight on phones and social media, and Gray’s link is drawn from patterns over time rather than a controlled experiment. But even the cautious reading lands in the same place: well-meaning adults protecting children from every risk may be quietly removing the practice they need.

Comfort feels like love. Sometimes it is. But sometimes the most loving thing is to let them carry the heavy bag, lose the match, sort out the falling-out, and come home a bit bruised and a lot stronger.

 

Seven ways to activate discipline and resilience

1. Give them real responsibility early.

A US study of nearly 10,000 children found that those who regularly did chores in their first year of school showed stronger self-competence, better peer relationships and higher life satisfaction three years later. Chores aren’t about a clean house. They’re about a child learning I am capable and I contribute.

Try this: Give every child a job that matters to the family, not just to them. A three-year-old can feed the cat. A ten-year-old can cook one dinner a week.

2. Let discomfort finish its work.

When your child is struggling, your instinct is to jump in. Hold on. Harvard’s research is clear that manageable stress, with a supportive adult nearby, is growth-promoting. The rescue cuts the lesson short.

Try this: Count to ten (silently, please) before you fix anything. Ask, “What have you tried?” before “Let me do it.”

3. Let them see you sweat.

In a 2017 MIT study, 15-month-old babies who watched an adult struggle and then succeed tried harder on their own task than babies who watched the adult succeed easily. Children learn that effort is worth it by watching us put in effort.

This one is personal for me. At 13 I didn’t like a lot about myself. Fitness changed that, and I’ve trained most days ever since. My children grew up watching me get up and go when I didn’t feel like it. I can’t prove that it rubbed off. But I’d bet on it.

Try this: Stop hiding your struggle. Say out loud, “This is hard, and I’m going to keep going.”

4. Praise the grind, not the gift.

Children who believe effort leads to achievement tend to outperform those who believe ability is fixed. “You’re so talented” teaches them to protect a label. ” You kept going when it got hard” teaches them to keep going.

Try this: Next time they win, ask about the training, not the trophy.

5. Build structure, then hand over the keys.

Routines and clear boundaries are scaffolding. But scaffolding is meant to come down. The Dunedin finding that self-control can grow is our cue to keep stretching the rope a little at a time, so the discipline becomes theirs, not ours.

Try this: Each year, hand one decision you used to make (bedtime on weekends, managing homework, budgeting pocket money) over to them, with the consequences.

6. Be their safe harbour

The single most common factor in children who show resilience, according to Harvard’s Center on the Developing Child, is at least one stable, committed relationship with a supportive adult. Not a perfect adult. A present one. This is what makes hard things tolerable instead of toxic.

Try this: After a setback, lead with connection (“That was tough, come here”) before correction (“Next time, maybe…”).

7. Give them a ‘why’ bigger than the moment.

Discipline is hard to sustain on willpower alone. Values, purpose and faith give children a reason to push through when motivation runs out. Every family needs its own version of “In this house, we finish what we start”, a line that carries weight on cold, early mornings.

Try this: Name your family’s three non-negotiable values out loud, and point them out when your child lives them.

 

Pressure makes diamonds (and so does grace)

As a woman of faith, none of this surprises me. Scripture got there long before the researchers: “tribulation worketh patience; and patience, experience; and experience, hope” (Romans 5:3–4, KJV). Discomfort isn’t the goal. Character is. Hope is. The struggle is just the road.

But notice what the research keeps whispering: the struggle works best when a child isn’t struggling alone. Our job isn’t to manufacture hardship or to remove it. It’s to let them face the right-sized challenges while knowing, without a shadow of doubt, that we’re in their corner.

Questions to sit with this week

  • What am I doing for my child that they could do for themselves?
  • When did I last let them fail at something small, and stay with them afterwards?
  • Are my rules held together by relationship, or just by my authority?
  • What does my child see me do when life gets hard?
  • Am I raising a child who is comfortable, or a child who is capable?

We can keep complaining that this generation isn’t resilient. Or we can look in the mirror and start building it, one chore, one disappointment, one warm hug after a hard day at a time.

The discomfort is the classroom. We just have to stop cancelling the lessons.

Keeping it real, Oyin

Sources

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Share the Post:

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *